Best Italian Restaurant in New York

Q: What are you known for?

We are known for Salads, Margherita Pizza, Gluten Free, Caprese, Gnocchi, Gluten Free Food, Chicken Wings, Garlic Knots, New York Italian Restaurant, Garlic Bread, Subs, Bruschetta, Chicken Parmesan, Boneless Wings, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Caesar Salad, Wraps, Antipasto Salad, Wings, Chicken Alfredo, Cannoli, Grilled Chicken Salad, Pizza, Ravioli, Catering, Meatballs, Vegetarian Food, Cheese Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks, Calzone, and Pasta

Experience an Authentic NYC Style Pizzeria and Deli!

Order online

Featuring

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Pasta Perfection

The components that go into our pasta are carefully chosen. We make sure that what we bring to the table is up to par with your discerning tastes, from our premium noodles to our hearty sauces.

Fresh From the Oven Pizzas

We make sure to give you wonderful meals at our restaurant. Our pizzas are a fantastic example; we make sure they are fresh from the oven for you.

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

What our guests are saying

Highly recommend! Sub and pizza were fantastic as well as the staff!

Patrick B.

Fantastic food. A massive win for Penfield.

Riley C.

The pizza was Amazing! This will be my go to place! Accurate wait times and great staff!

Jackalyn I.

Tried this place tonight for the first time. My mom is a picky eater and even she raved about her meal. Everything we got was delicious!!! Very impressed. Found our new favorite take out place!

Abby L.

Great spot for Pizza and subs or anything they make..Always fresh and friendly staff.

Alex C.

Awesome pizza! Will be back for sure

Kelly B.

Capones Italian eatery Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Join Capones Italian eatery Rewards

About Us

Authentic Italian pizza, pasta, deli, this is our second location our first location is 1517 empire blvd Webster. We will have homemade subs, pizza, bread, desserts, meatballs, pasta salads, pre made meals to go. Family owned and operated.

Capones loves our Buffalo Bills!

With football around the corner what better way to kick off the season than with a signed Stefon Diggs football? Each order will get you a raffle ticket! September first we will pick the winner! So let’s get those orders coming in. 585-267-7588